THE ROY LAB
  • Home
  • Publications
    • Alzheimer's
    • Parkinson's
    • CRISPR/Gene Therapy
    • Trafficking/Cytoskeleton
  • People
  • Lab Photos
  • Lab Space
  • Alumni
  • PI Blog
  • Covers
  • Misc Stuff
    • Life in San Diego
    • Links to Journals
    • Movies
  • Training
  • Join us

Why are good papers rejected from good journals? Two of the most common reasons...

12/21/2015

21 Comments

 
Over the years I have had several colleagues come to me in utter frustration that their most recent papers have been rejected from good journals. And now, after wasting all this time, they will have to make do with wherever it can get published. "How can the Reviewer/Editor not see it?" is the most common lament. In many such cases I have offered to take a look. I cannot profess that my suggestions helped these authors get their oft-rejected papers in glossy journals - though this has sometimes been the case - these experiences allowed me to get some insight into why good papers are often rejected from good journals. Allow me to elaborate....
The first common reason for rejection is that the authors simply overestimate the significance of their findings. Your experiments may be rigorous, the question may be an important one in your field, and yet the significance of your findings to Science in general may be limited. This is just a fact that authors must realize. Science works in unpredictable, meandering ways. Often experiments that you think will change the world turn out to be pretty lame in the end, while side-projects spearheaded by naive, wide-eyed undergrads yield stunning insights. Thus the end product can be very different from the start, and it is important to objectively evaluate your final manuscript. This is very difficult of course, as authors are personally invested in their favorite projects. For trainees, often matters are made worse by mentors who insist on submitting everything to glossy journals, and an experienced ally who is not afraid to tell the truth is a big asset. However I have found that such friends are rare, and most people are happy to give superficial "positive feedback". This is completely worthless and I suggest that authors stay away from such "mentors".   

The second, perhaps more common, reason is that the authors simply do not clearly state the significance of their findings. Worse, they are completely unaware that they are not doing so. Most papers are written in a dry style, listing experiments in the exact sequence that they were done, with no effort made to engage the audience. The result is that the reader is slammed with a series of complicated experiments with no end in sight and fails to see the significance. It is a classic case of being lost in the trees and not seeing the forest, and I have seen it so many times its not funny. The Reviewer/Editor cannot see it because the writer is not stating it clearly! One obvious reason for this is that scientists get almost no training in writing. But I feel there is also a cultural problem that scientists don't think that it is important to write clearly. While they may not directly say this, few make any effort to learn how to write clearly. Whatever one thinks about writing is up to them, but having been on many study sections and reviewed numerous papers I am absolutely certain that clear writers are getting most of the prizes. 

So what can one do? Besides reading and re-reading the book on writing clearly ("On Writing Well" by William Zinsser) until the cows come home, one thing that helps me is to write the abstract first. I know that this is exactly the opposite of what the pundits preach, but I always write and re-write the abstract first (often languishing in it for weeks or months), until the sequence of events (and significance) is clear in my head. Sometimes this reveals major insights, and at other times it tells me that the Science is solid but its not that significant after all. Once this logic is clear, the paper can be written. Often this exercise also helps in framing/designing final follow up experiments, and that is a bonus. So happy thinking and happy writing!  

21 Comments
shivali link
11/27/2021 03:38:24 pm

This is exceptionally educational and supportive post in the blog posting world. All Your posts consistently give us some subjective things.thank you such a for sharing this post.

Reply
assignment editing service in USA link
1/2/2022 11:26:59 pm

In the realm of blog writing, this is a very instructional and supportive piece. Your blogs regularly provide us with some subjective information. thank you such a for sharing this post.

Reply
Delhi Massage Services link
6/1/2022 03:39:27 am


https://massage269362325.wordpress.com/
https://maleescortindelhi.escortbook.com/
https://adulteroticmassageserviceforfemale.escortbook.com/
https://websitepromotionsolutions.blogspot.com/

Reply
DICS link
6/1/2022 03:41:41 am

https://dicsfaridabad.com/
https://dicsfaridabad.com/#
https://dicsfaridabad.com/e-accounting.html
https://dicsfaridabad.com/web-development.html
https://dicsfaridabad.com/software-developement.html
https://dicsfaridabad.com/digital-marketing.html
https://dicsfaridabad.com/programing-languages.html
https://dicsfaridabad.com/multimedia-and-graphic.html
https://dicsfaridabad.com/e-commerce-development.html
https://dicsfaridabad.com/hardware-and-networking.html
https://dicsfaridabad.com/short-term.html
https://dicsfaridabad.com/student.html
https://dicsfaridabad.com/recruiters.html
https://dicsfaridabad.com/contact.html

Reply
escorts in lahore link
8/1/2022 05:54:09 am

Great info there. Learnt very much new stuff. Visit our website for booking with us

Reply
escorts in islamabad link
8/1/2022 05:55:48 am

Where Models and stars give their services. We are delivering our services in

Reply
escorts in karachi link
8/1/2022 05:56:39 am

I got too much interesting stuff on your blog. Book our escorts girls in over Pakistan

Reply
escorts in Lahore link
8/1/2022 05:57:17 am

I guess I am not the only one having all the enjoyment here

Reply
escorts in Islamabad link
8/1/2022 05:57:58 am

So delighted to this post. Lot of great stuff here. This is a very well written article.

Reply
escorts in karachi link
8/1/2022 05:58:37 am

The article looks magnificent, but it would be beneficial if you can share more about the suchlike subjects in the future

Reply
escorts in lahore link
8/1/2022 05:59:07 am

Excellent website! I adore how it is easy on my eyes it is.

Reply
escorts in islamabad link
8/1/2022 05:59:37 am

I really appreciate the way you have written your content.

Reply
escorts in karachi link
8/1/2022 06:00:08 am

Excellent post. I was reviewing this blog continuously, and I am impressed!

Reply
escorts in dubai link
8/1/2022 06:00:49 am

Very helpful and knowledgeable material in this post. Hope to see more from you in future.

Reply
escorts in Lahore link
8/1/2022 06:01:33 am

Excellent website! I adore how it is easy on my eyes it is.

Reply
escorts in islamabad link
8/1/2022 06:02:18 am

I got too much interesting stuff on your blog. I guess I am not the only one having all the enjoyment here

Reply
escorts in karachi link
8/1/2022 06:03:06 am

The article looks magnificent, but it would be beneficial if you can share more about the suchlike subjects in the future

Reply
||+91-9990013009|| Best Digital Marketing Course Institute In Faridabad | SEO | SMO | PPC | Near Me link
9/22/2022 01:44:54 am

https://weblabzit.com
https://weblabzit.com/about.html
https://weblabzit.com/graphic-designing.html
https://weblabzit.com/web-designing.html
https://weblabzit.com/ui-ux-designer.html
https://weblabzit.com/web-development.html
https://weblabzit.com/digital-marketing.html
https://weblabzit.com/Short-term-courses.html
https://weblabzit.com/contact.html
https://www.weblabz.in/digital_marketing_courses/

Reply
||+91-9990013009|| Best Digital Marketing Services Company Agency In Faridabad | SEO | SMO | PPC | Near Me link
9/22/2022 01:45:40 am

https://weblabz.in/
https://weblabz.in/about-us.html
https://weblabz.in/profile.html
https://weblabz.in/team.html
https://weblabz.in/digital-marketing.html
https://weblabz.in/social-media-marketing.html
https://weblabz.in/content-marketing.html
https://weblabz.in/lead-generation.html
https://weblabz.in/online-reputation-management.html
https://weblabz.in/seo-and-google-ads.html
https://weblabz.in/web-development.html
https://weblabz.in/app-development.html
https://weblabz.in/web-desiging-development.html
https://weblabz.in/ecommerce-website.html
https://weblabz.in/blog-development.html
https://weblabz.in/software-development.html
https://weblabz.in/company-profiling.html
https://weblabz.in/logo-designing.html
https://weblabz.in/media-planning-buying.html
https://weblabz.in/portfolio.html
https://weblabz.in/hosting.html
https://weblabz.in/blog.html
https://weblabz.in/contact.html

Reply
venus Sports link
3/9/2023 04:06:15 pm

Sports broadcasting, sports broadcasting overseas dividends, sports broadcasting dividends comparison, 24 o'clock sports broadcasting, overseas sports broadcasting, overseas real-time dividends, sports analysis, community, free sports broadcasting, overseas domestic sports broadcasting, sports analysis.
https://vs-tv.com/

Reply
شيخ روحاني link
3/13/2023 05:58:15 am

That is really attention-grabbing, You’re a very professional blogger.
I’ve joined your feed and sit up for in quest of more of your wonderful post.
Additionally, I have shared your site in my social networks

https://www.rauhane.net
https://wikimedia.cc
https://hurenberlin.com/
https://www.elso9.com/
https://www.s3udy.org/
https://www.eljnoub.com/
https://www.q8yat.org/
https://www.rauhane.net
https://www.jeouzal.org
https://www.alfalaki.net
https://www.jaouzal.org

Reply



Leave a Reply.

    Some old ones Reposted...

    8/18/13 - A Classification of PI's - find yours' in the list!

    7/6/12 - Way to a "Science paper"

    5/30/11 - 20/20 Hindsights

    9/30/11 - Evolution of a bizzare, new Idea

    11/17/2011 - Rationale for curiosty-driven research...
    lessons from a 4 year old

     
    1/28/12 - "GTFM" - hilarious article on grant writing!

    The PI Blog

    This blog exists because my wife seemed a bit tired of being the only recipient of my random pontifications on life and Science for many years; and gently encouraged me to vent in a blog instead. From time to time, I put down thoughts that occur to me as I naiively stumble through a life in Science - bestowed upon me by accident (literally!). Please keep in mind that these musings are rather obvious things of little or no use to anyone, and are certainly not personally  targeted in any way, even though they are obviously derived from my experiences. OK, enough said.   

    Archives

    December 2020
    November 2016
    May 2016
    February 2016
    December 2015
    September 2015
    August 2015
    July 2015
    May 2015
    April 2015
    March 2015
    February 2015
    January 2015
    October 2014
    September 2014
    July 2014
    May 2014
    March 2014
    December 2013
    November 2013
    September 2013
    August 2013
    May 2013
    April 2013
    March 2013
    December 2012
    October 2012
    September 2012
    August 2012
    July 2012
    June 2012
    April 2012
    March 2012
    February 2012
    January 2012
    November 2011
    October 2011
    September 2011
    July 2011
    June 2011
    May 2011

    Categories

    All

    RSS Feed

Powered by Create your own unique website with customizable templates.
  • Home
  • Publications
    • Alzheimer's
    • Parkinson's
    • CRISPR/Gene Therapy
    • Trafficking/Cytoskeleton
  • People
  • Lab Photos
  • Lab Space
  • Alumni
  • PI Blog
  • Covers
  • Misc Stuff
    • Life in San Diego
    • Links to Journals
    • Movies
  • Training
  • Join us